Add to compare

Differences Between Masticating And Centrifugal Juicers. Which One Should I Get?

Question: What is the difference between a masticating and a centrifugal juicer? And which one should I get? On this post, I hope you can find what you need.

Today, we see that there are many brands and models of electric juice extractors on the market and it may be a bit overwhelming to figure out which one is best for your needs, especially if you are selecting your first ever juicer.

However, when it comes down to it, all these different electric juice machines fall into two basic kinds; Masticating and Centrifugal Juicers. Without wasting much time, let’s see what these types of juicers are.

 

Centrifugal Juicers

These kind of juicing machines operate at very high Revolution Per Minute (RMP) and juice very quickly. This makes them the ideal choice for those short on time. The high-speed spinning motor turns a circular disc style blade that acts very similar to a cheese grater.

The teeth shred the food into a pulp, and the centrifugal motion pulls the juice out of the pulp and through the mesh filter, where it is funneled out of the juicer via a spigot. In most centrifugal juicers, the pulp, once most of the juice has been pulled out, is ejected into a separate collection chamber.

Centrifugal juicers work best with soft and hard fruits and vegetables, but not quite as well with leafy greens like kale or spinach, or with wheatgrass

PROS:
  • Depending on which make and model, you can purchase one very inexpensively
  • Large chute allows you to juice whole pieces of fruit or vegetables without chopping
  • Fast, easy to use and clean
  • Easy to find. Available in most department or retail stores
  • Great for beginner juicers trying to decide if juicing is right for them

CONS:
  • The high speed blade does not open the cell of the plant enough to extract all of its nutritional value
  • Not as efficient at juicing soft leafy greens like wheat grass, spinach, etc.
  • Because of the high speed, some of the nutritional content is lost
  • Unable to make nut butters, nut milks, baby foods, etc.
  • Can be very loud while operating

Check out some best centrifugal juicers

Breville 800JEXL Juice Fountain Elite 1000-Watt Juice Extractor

Breville 800JEXL provides commercial performance with home kitchen convenience, this juicer runs on 1000 watts with two speeds, 13,000 RPM or 6,500 RPM, for juicing hard and soft ingredients. Beautiful die-cast metal design and power combined.

Breville BJE510XL Juice Fountain Multi-Speed 900-Watt Juicer

The Breville BJE510 Juice Fountain Multi-Speed with variable speeds is a smart juicer that adjusts speed to extract the maximum juice with minimal waste. A built-in smart chip increases power to the cutting disc under heavy loads so juicing is accomplished as efficiently as possible.

Masticating Juicers

Masticating juicers are more expensive than centrifugal juicers. They are high-end juice extractors that are popular with juicing purists, they are also known to have numerous features that make juicing an easy task. The aim of this type of juicer is to create the most nutritious juices. These juicers also run at a very slow RPMs.

Juice drains out of the underside of the tube, while the pulp is squeezed out at the end of the tube. Because of the slower crushing and squeezing action, masticating juicers can process leafy greens and wheatgrass, and the juice that they produce will last much longer than juice made in a centrifugal juicer, which should be consumed right away as it starts losing nutrients nearly immediately.

PROS:
  • Low speed processes at 80 rpm, which prevents oxidation of the juice and preserves more nutrients
  • Juice can be stored and used for up to 72 hours
  • High yield of juice
  • Vertical design saves space
  • Innovative auto cleaning system of the Omega VRT cleans the screen while juicing for better efficiency
  • Juices wheat grass and other greens very efficiently
  • Great for making nut milks, sorbets, nut butters and baby food

CONS:
  • Masticating juicers can be more expensive to buy
  • Smaller chute requires cutting produce into small pieces. Celery can get caught in it quite easily and needs to be chopped ahead of time.
  • Masticating juicers take longer to clean and put together than centrifugal juicers

Check out some best masticating juicers

Omega VRT350 Heavy Duty Dual-Stage Vertical Single Auger Low Speed Juicer Silver

The Omega VRT350 vertical masticating style juicer features the high efficiency of a masticating style juicer in a vertical design. Sometimes referred to as a low speed juicer, the VRT processes at 80rpm, whereas most other juicers process at a speed of 1,650 to 15,000rpm.

Kuvings NJE-3580U Masticating Slow Juicer, Silver

The Kuvings Multi-Purpose Slow Juicer is the right choice for the health-conscious individuals who want greater variety in their daily juicing routine. It employs a low speed masticating technology for minimal heat build-up and oxidation and provides juice that is richer in healthy enzymes and vitamins.

Areas highlighted below are the main and common differences between the centrifugal and masticating juicers:

1

Design

Masticating juicers have a horizontal design, and the tube holding the auger extends out of the motorized base. Fruits and vegetables are shoved on top of the tube where they are crushed and squeezed by the auger to process juice while  centrifugal juicers have a vertical design where the food is pushed into a mesh chamber that rolls rapidly featuring a needle-like tooth on its floor.

2

Speed and Spinning

Masticating juicers crush the food in a very slow method such that there is no scrapping, which is created. This means that no heat build-up will occur. The slow press makes sure that the enzymes in the food are not killed, and that the process of oxidation is lessened. This makes the juicer a great choice for many people. On the other hand, centrifugal juicers have a high circle force which causes a lot of friction.

3

Oxidation

If you are using a centrifugal juicer to produce fresh juices, the possibilities are that oxidation is likely to decay your juice. The enzymes inside the juice will start to decline when they are exposed to oxygen. However, masticating juicers slow down the oxidation process, and this is very important in maintaining the enzymes and other nutrients contained in the food.

4

Yield  and Pulp

A masticating juicer is more expensive than a centrifugal juicer. It gives you 20 percent more juice than you would get if you are using a centrifugal juicer. As a result, you end up purchasing lesser fruits and get a high yield of juice thus saving your money.  The pulp that is left when you operate a masticating juicer is much dry than the one produced by a centrifugal juicer. This is an indication that the machine is able to extract all the fluids from the foods being processed.

5

Ease of Cleaning

Having a juicer that is hard to clean will compromise the quality of juices being produced. If you live an occupied lifestyle, and do not have enough time to do your stuff, you can consider going for a masticating juicer since it is easier to clean as compared to centrifugal juicers.

6

Versatility and Flexibility

It is suitable to spend your money in a flexible machine that can handle almost every task. For instance, a centrifugal juicer will only work perfectly with soft and hard vegetables. This insinuates that you cannot use the machine when you need to produce juices from wheatgrass or other leafy vegetables while a masticating juicer is a flexible and versatile machine that you can use to produce sorbets, nut butter, and baby food among others.

7

Nutrition and Juice Flavor

A masticating juicer will, without any doubt, give you very tasty and delicious juices. Hugely many people change from centrifugal juicers to masticating juicers because of the taste of juices produced by these machines.

8

Price

Centrifugal juicers are very familiar because they are much affordable. They come with affordable prices when compared to masticating juicers but do not offer quality juices as masticating juicers does. Despite the fact that masticating juicers are quite pricey, they are tough machines that will last for a long period of time and still give you high quality and nutritional juices.

Final Words

Masticating juicers have the longest warranty in the industry. They are unmatched when it comes to providing customers with assurance. For instance, Omega and Kuvings Juicers offers 10-15 years product warranty (both body and motor).  This is indeed a great advantage of the masticating juicers over the centrifugal juicers.

However, centrifugal juicers, because of the high speed motor easily develop fault. These type of juicers offer 1-3 years warranty. This cannot be compared with their masticating counterparts. A great and popular company that produces centrifugal juicers is Breville.

In conclusion, if you are preparing to juice for a long period of time, a masticating juicer will be a good choice. These machines have a moderate operation and produce fewer noises.

In Conclusion

I want a masticating juicer because:

  • I want to make my juice ahead of time and be able to store it longer than a centrifuge
  • I don’t have a lot of extra space in my kitchen
  • I can invest in a moderately expensive juicer
  • I want to be able to juice everything

I want a centrifugal juicer because:

  • I need something quick and easy
  • I may have children using the juicer and want then to enjoy the process
  • I need something less expensive and want to see if I will continue juicing over time
  • I don’t care that I can’t juice soft leafy greens very well

Shares
Best Juicers Review
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
0